Denying having privilege is invalidating to those who are at a disadvantage. Almost as if denying that there is any inequity. If we lived in a perfect world then everything would be equal there would be no privilege, and everyone would have the same rights and power as each other. When there is inequity there is a power struggle and an unfair distribution of advantages. So someone who is part of a privileged group saying that they do not have any privilege can make it appear life is the former, completely equity for everyone. When we all know that it is not and this is very apparent in Johnson's text as he includes anecdotes and goes through all of the -isms that groups face. This is why having defenses is so harmful, it causes people to push aside that there are others out there at a disadvantage because of personal advantages.
It is also important to acknowledge that just because a person is a part of one privileged group it does not mean they are privileged in every way of the diversity wheel. There are still hardships that people face, no matter what privilege you may have, it does not make you immune to life's struggles. Even with those difficulties, you still may hold an advantage that someone else may not have. For example, I am privileged by my whiteness, middle-class upbringing, education, access to food, health care, and basic resources. There are parts that I do not benefit from such as my female gender but that does not take away from the fact that I possess this much privilege just from being born into it.
There needs to be an open dialogue when discussing privilege and that point is stressed through Johnson’s chapters. We need to let go of the guilt and the defensiveness that we feel when trying to have this conversation. Without this, we will never be able to work together to equalize power. Understandably, privilege and power can be a tricky or uncomfortable conversation to have. We of course do not want a misunderstanding, and we want to frame it in a way that inspires motivation towards change and more conversations.
What are some good opening ideas to talk about privilege that both hold empathy but still move the conversion along?
This is a rendering of a diversity wheel!
It illustrates the multiple layers of understanding our individuality,
This is the link to an article by an experienced social worker, and her tips on having this conversation about privilege!
https://www.globalcitizen.org/en/content/why-its-important-to-think-about-privilege-and-why/

I really liked your comments about how there is nothing wrong with being a part of a privileged group, but denying that you re privileged is invalidating to those at a disadvantage. We have created a culture where many people take things to the extreme. Privilege does not have to equal intolerant or part of the problem, being a part of a privileged group just means they have they ability to do something about the disparities.
ReplyDeleteHi Sara! I really enjoyed your points made about the need to have dicussions regarding privilege and the role privilege plays in our society even if these dicussions can be uncomfortable or tricky. Additionally I loved how you said these discussions should be motivational for change, not shameful! Great work!
ReplyDeleteI agree with you when you say that it is important to have conversations about different privileges in our society. Denying privilege will only steer us away from acknowledging different problems many people around us face on a daily basis. People should not be ashamed or discouraged to have these difficult conversations, but should rather be inspired to help others and make a change within the community.
ReplyDeleteSara, I agree with all of your points about how as a society privilege needs to be understood and addressed. Without addressing our power and privilege differences we cannot come to accept everyone and give everyone the same opportunities.
ReplyDelete