Thursday, February 29, 2024

Tatum; Connections (Blog #6)

  Can We Talk an excerpt from the book Why Are All the Black Kids Sitting Together in the Cafeteria by Beverly Daniel Tatum is centered around the discussion of what racism is, how racism is destructive, and Social Segregation. Racism is not just an individual or personal idea, it is also a cultural belief and institutionalized system. This is an unjust system because it provides one racial group with an advantage, leaving the other groups with a lack of those privileges. Social Segregation is what occurs when a group that surrounds an individual influences their opinions on other groups through second-hand experiences. All of these concepts can be connected to other articles we have read in class.

A key point in Tatum's excerpt is that no one is completely innocent of prejudice. From when we were young we had these second-hand experiences from those in our communities and typically they may be similar to our culture. From them, we gained ideas on how other groups operate and unconsciously formed prejudice. Similarly in Johnson's article Power, Privilege, and Difference there is an exploration of how we have some level of prejudice and privilege. Whether we mean to or not, we do have prejudice. It is understandable to have these preconceived notions because we were fed them when we were too young to be conscious of the systems at play. Once we do become aware it is important to have dialogues with others, communicate, and understand other perspectives to remove ourselves from prejudice. 


Tatum introduces the analogy that prejudice is like smog in a racist society. Some days the prejudice is thick and easy to see. Other days you would not even notice it is there. No matter what, we are always breathing it in. Although that does not mean we have to suffer from pollution, there are ways to change and reduce the smog in the environment. In Delpit’s article The Silenced Dialogue we are also presented with these ideas of change. Delpit stressed that teachers are the ones with the power to change. As future educators, we have the capability to reduce the pollution of prejudice by educating our students on issues in the world so they are able to build skills in battling the institutional structures that have been set in place. As Tatum emphasizes racism is not just individuals' opinions, there are cultural beliefs (social segregation) and institutions that play into the whole system. It is important to empower and educate students so they are able to speak about these issues and break the system of struggle and disadvantage.  


This article Understanding Racism, discusses what is racism and the damages of colorblindness. It reminds us it is important to ask yourself if you are challenging these systems! 





Thursday, February 22, 2024

Crenshaw; Argument (Blog #5)

 KimberlĂ© Crenshaw argues that intersectionality is valid and should be respected in society. Intersection is defined as the overlapping of social categorizations (such as race, gender, or sexuality). When only one aspect of a person's identity is recognized other parts of their identity may be ignored. 

Crenshaw includes a car intersection analogy to clarify her idea of intersectionality. A car intersection is where two or more roads meet. So imagine this intersection is a person, each road is a different part of their identity and where they all meet (the intersection) is their whole identity. As an example, the horizontal road may be a gender and the vertical road may be religion. These two identities are completely unrelated to each other but still have a massive impact on this person. Crenshaw then includes how injustice can go unhelped at these intersections. Imagine that the law is an ambulance, this ambulance can only travel on one road and help one identity, completely disregarding all of the other identities that may be at a disadvantage.

Crenshaw also provides a real anecdote that brings attention to those who have suffered due to the lack of recognition of intersectionality. She tells us about Emma DeGraffenreid and her denial of a job position. DeGraffenreid is both African American and a woman, two separate identities, and believed she was turned down from a job because those parts of her identity intersected. When she pursued legal action, she was pushed to the side because the courts were able to prove that they hired both African Americans and women (not an intersection; only a part of one group). Although that was not her point, it was that they did not hire African American women (intersection; a part of both groups). 

This is a serious problem, Emma was being discriminated against and the law was not protecting her. As Crenshaw states “If you cannot see a problem you cannot face it” (The Urgency of Intersectionality at 8:50). If the law continues to neglect the issues with intersectionality then there will be no solution. Crenshaw stresses that we must bring awareness to this issue because countless people are disadvantaged. 

At the end of this Ted Talk, she shares the names and stories of black women who have died at the hands of brutality but their stories are overlooked due to intersectionality. This evoked a very emotional reaction in an attempt to motivate change.

Through her argument, she used analogies to create a fuller understanding of intersectionality, provided anecdotes to emphasize the damage of neglecting intersectionality, and brought awareness to those who have suffered. My question to the class is what part of this argument stuck out to you the most? The article The Intersectionality of Diversity provides a breakdown of the layers of intersectionality and how to implement valuing intersectionality in society.

Sunday, February 18, 2024

Khon, Culturally Relevant Pedagogy; Reflection (Blog #4)

 Different settings can evoke different emotional responses. Alfie Kohn explores this in the article, What to Look for in a Classroom. Through a chart, he explores different aspects of a classroom and what a good and worrying sign would be in that classroom. I am going to reflect on my experiences within different types of classrooms!

When someone walks into a room the teaching methods of the teacher can be reflected without even meeting them. How the seats are arranged or how the textbooks are stored in the room can provide a clear idea of whether the teacher is controlling, organized, or easy-going. Personally, I enjoy cluttered classrooms. Galleries of former students' work are taped to the wall and books are stuffed into the shelves. It feels comfortable and homey, the environment does not feel competitive, rather it focuses on learning. 

I went to East Providence High School both the old one (that has been torn down) and the newly built one. Almost every classroom in the old high school was exactly as homey as listed before. It felt as if I was walking into the teacher's other home, everything stored within it was very personal and loved. 

I am extremely appreciative to have had the opportunity to go to the new high school that was very up-to-date and modern. While I am grateful for it, this article focuses on how a classroom can feel and my experience was not always positive in the new school. I found that the classrooms were very stark. Teachers were not allowed to tape anything to the walls, and no student work or posters were on the wall. Also, teachers moved around to different classrooms, not giving them the ability to leave things in the classrooms. It often felt uncomfortable and sterile in those rooms, which is not the best emotion to feel while trying to concentrate on learning. 

Although physical items are not the only things to decide the learning environment of classrooms. A lot of the teachers I had in the new building were still great! The teacher would move around and engage with the students and give us interesting tasks and assignments to work on. Throughout the school years I spent there it became more and more comfortable; especially after knowing the teacher and their sneaky attempts to personalize the classrooms. In my future classrooms, I really want to incorporate this homey and engaging environment so that my students are comfortable while learning! This article, Creating a Safe Learning Environment provides tips on creating a welcoming atmosphere for students.


Wednesday, February 7, 2024

Kozol; Hyperlinks (Blog #3)

Amazing Grace by Jonathan Kozol provides insight into the difficult living conditions of those housed in the impoverished parts of New York. There is gore and pain, even in areas of salvation such as St. Ann’s church, there still is violence surrounding it. There may be homes for people to live in but not enough blankets to keep them warm. Humiliation is felt when trash and incinerators are left there as if these areas are not people's homes. The lines for condoms and clean needles are long but not as long as the day's people must wait to receive medical care. Heartbreak is felt as struggles with welfare are brought to light and called out for their damaged system. While reading this, I found it both shocking and hooked to learn more. Throughout this blog, I will explore different media that provide more detail on specific areas mentioned in this article. 


 

In Amazing Grace, the first thing Kozol informs the readers to spark interest is how a train in New York, from Manhattan to the South Bronx, can travel from one of the richest neighborhoods and end in one of the poorest. I was curious as to why a place that may be flourishing can be just a train ride away is a place in total disrepair.  In the article, How Do Rich Neighborhoods Exist So Close to Poor Ones? (link) it is explained a separation between wealthier and poorer neighborhoods is how much upward mobility the community can offer. Upward mobility is having the ability to earn more than your past generations (such as your parents). Raj Chetty explored areas that had the most upward mobility and those that did not. The areas warmer-toned have less upward mobility, but if we look at them more in-depth within those red zones there are cool-toned colors that show there is a lot of upward mobility. This is due to economic prospects (organization of the money, industry, and trade) that will tend to exist around very short gaps. This is a big concern because it can be very discouraging, especially to see good schools that are close but right out of your child's reach. However, there have been programs that team up to try and help parents with housing vouchers to have them move closer to higher mobility areas with better schooling.


Living in impoverished conditions can be very detrimental to children's education. Several other factors and struggles can take precedence over education but, not attending school will cause an increase in downward mobility. Many students living in poverty tend to start school already behind those who do not. This scientific literature article, The Impact of Poverty on Educational Outcomes for Children, presents intervention and what we can do to help. This article also discusses what poverty looks like, but a lot of that is already presented in Amazing Grace (although there are some interesting statistics if you would like to view them in this link!). But overall we see the struggles with welfare and how the system is breaking when we see how Alice Washington shares troubling stories of those she has worked with. From watching a high school graduate and scholarship winner turn into a drug addict to having to change her sheets in the hospital due to the lack of service. There are so many struggles that get in the way of life it is easy to put less dire situations on the back burner. What can we do to prevent the negative impact poverty leaves on children's education? This article suggests we advocate for equity of outcomes and support in schools (such as intervention programs). Also, advocate for quality early education so children have higher readiness when enter schools.



Also, this is a gallery of what wage-gapped neighborhoods look like together and I thought it might be interesting :)

https://www.lovemoney.com/galleries/100302/cities-where-wealth-and-poverty-sit-starkly-side-by-side?page=1

 

Sunday, February 4, 2024

Lake, Delpit; Quotes (Blog #2)

 This week we explored texts that discussed power dynamics within the classroom. One text was An Indian Father Plea by Robert Lake. This is a first-person account of Lake’s son being treated differently due to their culture not fitting the culture of power within the school. It showed the perspective of struggling against those in power to try and achieve equity. Other Peoples Children by Lisa Delpit viewed these cultural patterns in a wide scope of the world but also how those patterns appear in classrooms. Her solution to the dilemma of one culture having power over another is to have a conversation about the fundamental issues of power, where everyone can speak. Those who are at a disadvantage need to be allowed to share their qualitative feelings. The quotes I explore from these texts suggest thought patterns and actions that can be done to support Lake and Delpit's notions. 

Quote #1: “My son…is not an empty glass coming into your class to be filled. He is a full basket coming into a different environment and society with something special to share” (Lake). As future educators, it is important to remember that these students are entering the classroom with personal lives. They are not just a blank canvas to be filled with knowledge. They are people who already have a very diverse set of skills and knowledge. I feel that it is important to never allow those interests to be taken from them because they do not fit a specific style of teaching or opinions. Rather, respect their diversity and who they are as individuals, instead of only acknowledging what you or the majority feels is most valued.


Quote #2: “The teacher cannot be the only expert in the classroom. To deny student's expert knowledge is to disempower them” (Delpit). As mentioned students come into a classroom with all different skills and knowledge that stem from their interests. Use that to engage them in your lessons. There is a higher likelihood that students will be motivated to learn when it includes something they genuinely enjoy. We see this in Delpit's example of Amanda Branscomebe using rap songs to practice analyzing literature and grammar. Since those students were engaged with what they were learning they quickly gained the skills to similarly analyze works of Shakespeare. Proving that skills learned from different media still translate to valuable abilities. The teacher and students were able to combine what they were experts in to create the best outcome for everyone. 


Quote #3: “We must become ethnographers in the true sense. Teachers are in an ideal position to play this role, to attempt…to initiate true dialogue” (Delpit). Teachers have a lot of power when it comes to shaping their student's minds. Of course, students can form their own opinions outside of the classroom but teachers can easily share information with the students, and the students more or less have to participate if they want to succeed in that class. Teachers can be the ones to understand cultures (like ethnographers) and share that information with their students. The students can become prepared and more informed, helping them have an educated opinion that can lead to a beneficial dialogue. 

This article, Best Practices for Creating an Inclusive Classroom, can help generate some ideas on how to be more inclusive in the classroom. Also, some suggestions on how to handle discrimination in the classroom that may arise due to inclusivity.


Blog #11

The video Precious Knowledge stood out to me. Seeing the effect that a strong curriculum and supportive teachers have on a student's edu...