Kimberlé Crenshaw argues that intersectionality is valid and should be respected in society. Intersection is defined as the overlapping of social categorizations (such as race, gender, or sexuality). When only one aspect of a person's identity is recognized other parts of their identity may be ignored.
Crenshaw includes a car intersection analogy to clarify her idea of intersectionality. A car intersection is where two or more roads meet. So imagine this intersection is a person, each road is a different part of their identity and where they all meet (the intersection) is their whole identity. As an example, the horizontal road may be a gender and the vertical road may be religion. These two identities are completely unrelated to each other but still have a massive impact on this person. Crenshaw then includes how injustice can go unhelped at these intersections. Imagine that the law is an ambulance, this ambulance can only travel on one road and help one identity, completely disregarding all of the other identities that may be at a disadvantage.
Crenshaw also provides a real anecdote that brings attention to those who have suffered due to the lack of recognition of intersectionality. She tells us about Emma DeGraffenreid and her denial of a job position. DeGraffenreid is both African American and a woman, two separate identities, and believed she was turned down from a job because those parts of her identity intersected. When she pursued legal action, she was pushed to the side because the courts were able to prove that they hired both African Americans and women (not an intersection; only a part of one group). Although that was not her point, it was that they did not hire African American women (intersection; a part of both groups).
This is a serious problem, Emma was being discriminated against and the law was not protecting her. As Crenshaw states “If you cannot see a problem you cannot face it” (The Urgency of Intersectionality at 8:50). If the law continues to neglect the issues with intersectionality then there will be no solution. Crenshaw stresses that we must bring awareness to this issue because countless people are disadvantaged.
At the end of this Ted Talk, she shares the names and stories of black women who have died at the hands of brutality but their stories are overlooked due to intersectionality. This evoked a very emotional reaction in an attempt to motivate change.
Through her argument, she used analogies to create a fuller understanding of intersectionality, provided anecdotes to emphasize the damage of neglecting intersectionality, and brought awareness to those who have suffered. My question to the class is what part of this argument stuck out to you the most? The article The Intersectionality of Diversity provides a breakdown of the layers of intersectionality and how to implement valuing intersectionality in society.
Sara, I like how you further explained Crenshaw's intersection analogy. With Crenshaw's argument, she emphasized not separating parts of a person's identity but looking at them all together. I think you did a really great job of explaining the main points of Crenshaw's Ted Talk.
ReplyDeleteSara, I love how you described intersectionality with Crenshaw's literal intersection analogy. The way you summarized the main points of the video is also really easy to understand and comprehend. Great work!
ReplyDelete