Amazing Grace by Jonathan Kozol provides insight into the difficult living conditions of those housed in the impoverished parts of New York. There is gore and pain, even in areas of salvation such as St. Ann’s church, there still is violence surrounding it. There may be homes for people to live in but not enough blankets to keep them warm. Humiliation is felt when trash and incinerators are left there as if these areas are not people's homes. The lines for condoms and clean needles are long but not as long as the day's people must wait to receive medical care. Heartbreak is felt as struggles with welfare are brought to light and called out for their damaged system. While reading this, I found it both shocking and hooked to learn more. Throughout this blog, I will explore different media that provide more detail on specific areas mentioned in this article.
In Amazing Grace, the first thing Kozol informs the readers to spark interest is how a train in New York, from Manhattan to the South Bronx, can travel from one of the richest neighborhoods and end in one of the poorest. I was curious as to why a place that may be flourishing can be just a train ride away is a place in total disrepair. In the article, How Do Rich Neighborhoods Exist So Close to Poor Ones? (link) it is explained a separation between wealthier and poorer neighborhoods is how much upward mobility the community can offer. Upward mobility is having the ability to earn more than your past generations (such as your parents). Raj Chetty explored areas that had the most upward mobility and those that did not. The areas warmer-toned have less upward mobility, but if we look at them more in-depth within those red zones there are cool-toned colors that show there is a lot of upward mobility. This is due to economic prospects (organization of the money, industry, and trade) that will tend to exist around very short gaps. This is a big concern because it can be very discouraging, especially to see good schools that are close but right out of your child's reach. However, there have been programs that team up to try and help parents with housing vouchers to have them move closer to higher mobility areas with better schooling.
Living in impoverished conditions can be very detrimental to children's education. Several other factors and struggles can take precedence over education but, not attending school will cause an increase in downward mobility. Many students living in poverty tend to start school already behind those who do not. This scientific literature article, The Impact of Poverty on Educational Outcomes for Children, presents intervention and what we can do to help. This article also discusses what poverty looks like, but a lot of that is already presented in Amazing Grace (although there are some interesting statistics if you would like to view them in this link!). But overall we see the struggles with welfare and how the system is breaking when we see how Alice Washington shares troubling stories of those she has worked with. From watching a high school graduate and scholarship winner turn into a drug addict to having to change her sheets in the hospital due to the lack of service. There are so many struggles that get in the way of life it is easy to put less dire situations on the back burner. What can we do to prevent the negative impact poverty leaves on children's education? This article suggests we advocate for equity of outcomes and support in schools (such as intervention programs). Also, advocate for quality early education so children have higher readiness when enter schools.
Also, this is a gallery of what wage-gapped neighborhoods look like together and I thought it might be interesting :)
Hi Sara! I really enjoyed how you were able to find an article that talked about how much educational poverty affects children. I felt like this article really related well to what Kozol was trying to hit home. I also really like the image you chose to include on the your blog because it is very informative :)
ReplyDeleteI really appreciated the map delineating upward mobility in the US. I think that really helps put things into perspective.
ReplyDeleteHey, it seems like you went above and beyond in explaining the Kozol article! I really enjoyed the paragraph that included the hyperlink "How Do Rich Neighborhoods Exist So Close To Poor Ones?" because I think it expands on Kozols point on how the South Bronx can be so devastating but be so close to Manhattan.
ReplyDelete