Sunday, February 4, 2024

Lake, Delpit; Quotes (Blog #2)

 This week we explored texts that discussed power dynamics within the classroom. One text was An Indian Father Plea by Robert Lake. This is a first-person account of Lake’s son being treated differently due to their culture not fitting the culture of power within the school. It showed the perspective of struggling against those in power to try and achieve equity. Other Peoples Children by Lisa Delpit viewed these cultural patterns in a wide scope of the world but also how those patterns appear in classrooms. Her solution to the dilemma of one culture having power over another is to have a conversation about the fundamental issues of power, where everyone can speak. Those who are at a disadvantage need to be allowed to share their qualitative feelings. The quotes I explore from these texts suggest thought patterns and actions that can be done to support Lake and Delpit's notions. 

Quote #1: “My son…is not an empty glass coming into your class to be filled. He is a full basket coming into a different environment and society with something special to share” (Lake). As future educators, it is important to remember that these students are entering the classroom with personal lives. They are not just a blank canvas to be filled with knowledge. They are people who already have a very diverse set of skills and knowledge. I feel that it is important to never allow those interests to be taken from them because they do not fit a specific style of teaching or opinions. Rather, respect their diversity and who they are as individuals, instead of only acknowledging what you or the majority feels is most valued.


Quote #2: “The teacher cannot be the only expert in the classroom. To deny student's expert knowledge is to disempower them” (Delpit). As mentioned students come into a classroom with all different skills and knowledge that stem from their interests. Use that to engage them in your lessons. There is a higher likelihood that students will be motivated to learn when it includes something they genuinely enjoy. We see this in Delpit's example of Amanda Branscomebe using rap songs to practice analyzing literature and grammar. Since those students were engaged with what they were learning they quickly gained the skills to similarly analyze works of Shakespeare. Proving that skills learned from different media still translate to valuable abilities. The teacher and students were able to combine what they were experts in to create the best outcome for everyone. 


Quote #3: “We must become ethnographers in the true sense. Teachers are in an ideal position to play this role, to attempt…to initiate true dialogue” (Delpit). Teachers have a lot of power when it comes to shaping their student's minds. Of course, students can form their own opinions outside of the classroom but teachers can easily share information with the students, and the students more or less have to participate if they want to succeed in that class. Teachers can be the ones to understand cultures (like ethnographers) and share that information with their students. The students can become prepared and more informed, helping them have an educated opinion that can lead to a beneficial dialogue. 

This article, Best Practices for Creating an Inclusive Classroom, can help generate some ideas on how to be more inclusive in the classroom. Also, some suggestions on how to handle discrimination in the classroom that may arise due to inclusivity.


4 comments:

  1. Hi Sara, I like your interpretation of the first quote. It's time that educators understand that students have a life outside of school, meaning that they were already exposed to different experiences in life. Now more than ever we need loving and understanding educators who support their students.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Sara! I really enjoyed the image and quotes you picked to help explain this week's reading. I love your explanations to all of the quotes but I especially enjoyed the second quote. I like how you mentioned that we need to engage students by using their interests to make learning basics more enjoyable for them :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Sara, I really like the second quote you chose. That one stood out to me while I was reading as well. I think it's important to remember that everyone has different experiences and background knowledge. And as future educators, we need to take that into account. Some students will already have their own take on a certain topic, making them experts in their own right.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Link does not work. Is this the Walden University articlle?

    ReplyDelete

Blog #11

The video Precious Knowledge stood out to me. Seeing the effect that a strong curriculum and supportive teachers have on a student's edu...